A lot’s been going around over the last week or so about a report issued by the Missouri Information Analysis Center (MIAC), an intelligence clearinghouse or fushion center that feeds information to law enforcement entities in Missouri. The report states that there are militias that conduct domestic terrorist activities and that you can tell who they are by bumperstickers advertising the Libertarian Party, the Constitution Party, the Campaign for Liberty (and their associated political candidates like Congressman Ron Paul and former Congressman Bob Barr). There’s been such a buzz on the blogosphere that I decided to wait it out before putting fingers to keyboard. Since it’s started to receive some mainstream media coverage, there are now videos available that cover the issue, such as the following Glenn Beck and Penn Gillette conversation:
The MIAC report is flawed (err, you know, as in completely wrong and misinformed) in a number of ways.
First and foremost, a person’s peaceful associations do not translate into making that person associated with violent groups. Specifically, in the case of card-carrying Libertarians, we carry cards that specifically state that we will not initiate force to achieve political, social, and/or economic goals (unless this has changed since the last time I renewed my membership). Anyway, the adoption and adherence to a non-initiation of force principle makes for a lousy potential to be terrorists.
The second major flaw is that the report assumes every person in a militia-type of organization is violent or intends to initiate force. Having met people claiming to be involved in such organizations (which is nearly impossible not to if you live in a rural area of middle America), I really wouldn’t be too afraid of them. Those I’ve met have been old, overweight, ex-US military members who are simply concerned about where the country is heading. They have families and children, they attend church, and they think that the Constitution’s a good thing. That describes a large majority of all our neighbors (and they were always so quiet). I wouldn’t be surprised if there aren’t even elected politicians (especially from the mountainous Western states) who had some sort of formal militia ties. Luckily for me, I forgot the names and whereabouts of all these random persons that I bumped into in all of my wilderness excursions and wouldn’t be able to tell you a thing about them (especially under conditions of extreme torture).
The big unfortunate in this situation is that a lot of people will leave this as Libertarians being singled out, so why care? It’s Libertarians today, but maybe it’ll be you tomorrow. And in preparation, the Department of Homeland Security’s got a number of intelligence fusion centers at the ready in your state.
H/T: The Smoking Argus, Deleware Libertarian, Kn@ppster, Independent Political Report, and others